Wilson and Alroy's Record Reviews We listen to the lousy records so you won't have to.

 Main page 

 New additions 

 Pop: 00s  90s 80s 70s 60s 50s

 Latin/Jazz 

 Top 20: DBW JA 

 E-mail 

LL Cool J


Reviewed on this page:
Radio - Bigger And Deffer - Walking With A Panther - Mama Said Knock You Out - 14 Shots To The Dome - mr. smith - Phenomenon - G.O.A.T.: Greatest Of All Time - 10 - The DEFinition


LL Cool J (given name: James T. Smith) was probably the best looking of the early/mid 80s rappers, and he's exploited his sex appeal to the max (his stage name stands for "Ladies Love Cool James"). But there's a lot more to LL than that; he's got an incredible voice that moves from a powerful roar to a gentle bedside croon - he has more emotional range than any other rapper I've heard, when he chooses to use it. Unfortunately, most of his later albums have been recorded on auto-pilot, so tread carefully. (DBW)


Radio (1985)
Rick Rubin's first hit production, and his ultra-spare style works wonders here, leaving plenty of room for LL's enormous voice on tracks like "Can't Live Without My Radio" and "I Need A Beat." Even the minor tracks are clever: "That's A Lie," "You Can't Dance." "I Want You" and "I Can Give You More" may or may not be the first hip-hop ballads, but either way they're smooth, tender and very effective. (DBW)

Bigger And Deffer (1987)
A mixed bag, with his best boasting song ("I'm Bad" keeps the hilarious couplets coming so fast you're usually laughing too hard to keep up), a hit ballad ("I Need Love"), and an ode to a neighborhood institution that cracks you up in spite of yourself ("Bristol Hotel"). Otherwise, there are some misfired experiments ("Go, Cut Creator, Go" samples Chuck Berry, changes tempo, uses detuned heavy guitar chords and leaves you shaking your head) and a fair amount of filler. (DBW)

Walking With A Panther (1988)
Produced by LL, and like its predecessor it's uneven: the best moments are the slow, sax-accented story of Hollywood excess "Goin' Back To Cali" (the B-side "Jack The Ripper," which didn't make the album, is even better); "Clap Your Hands" mixes live rhythm guitar and off-the-wall samples; "It Gets No Rougher" and "Nitro" are coproduced by the Bomb Squad in their signature style; "You're My Heart" is another love song, this time with ethereal keys. But LL indulges his macho side to a distressing degree with the mindless 2 Live Crew-style "Big Ole Butt," "I'm That Type Of Guy," "1-900 LL Cool J" and so on, plus a silly social conscious message tune ("Change Your Ways"), and a sappy attempt to integrate sung vocals ("Two Different Worlds" featuring Cyndé Monet). (DBW)

Mama Said Knock You Out (1990)
"Don't call it a comeback," LL says on the title track (which samples Sly and the Family Stone's "Trip To Your Heart"), but I can't think of anything else to call it. Produced by Marley Marl, it's a lot more varied than Panther, with the new-jack swing "Around The Way Girl," the frantic remix of "Jinglin' Baby" and the streetcorner "To Da Break Of Dawn." And there are lots of great rhymes, like "Cheesy Rat Blues," the tale of his sales slump ("I go to the mall/They throw my old tapes at me"), and "Illegal Search," a shoutout to racist cops everywhere. (Consumer warning: seeing the film Fear Of A Black Hat may render you unable to listen to "Mama Said Knock You Out" without dissolving in hysterics.) (DBW)

14 Shots To The Dome (1993)
A routine follow-up, with a couple of unsuccessful experiments ("Crossroads" features a full string section), a nice love song ("Pink Cookies In A Plastic Bag Getting Crushed By Buildings"), and all of LL's usual bag of tricks, but there's nothing here he hadn't done better before. (DBW)

mr. smith (1995)
LL's stopped experimenting here; he has tune after tune that's based on one sample (generally early 80s soft-soul) and raps about his usual subjects: love, hip hop, and himself. The album's been more successful than anything he's done before, either because of his TV series or for some other reason. He has a couple of dirty-talk songs (guest star LeShaun outraunches him on "Doin It") that will probably of most interest to thirteen year olds, and tries to be hardcore on "I Shot Ya," but he's never been a convincing gangsta. He's at his best as a wistful, love-struck loser on "Hey Lover," which has backing vocals from Boys II Men - the lyrics are poignant and real. (DBW)

Phenomenon (1997)
Most tracks were produced by either Poke and Tone or Puffy Combs, and if you're guessing that means faceless hip-pop based on samples from huge hits, you win the prize ("Candy," based on New Edition's cheesy "Candy Girl"). The title track, based on the hook from Melle Mel's "White Lines," was a single, and it illustrates the dull emptiness of the project... LL just talks about how great he is, without any of the witty wordplay, emotional honesty or charisma that really did make his early records great. But he does pull off the George Michael-sampling, choir-employing, soul-baring, tear-jerking "Father," with genuine feeling that's strikingly absent from the rest of the album. "4, 3, 2, 1" features Method Man, Redman, Canibus and DMX rapping over a reggae groove; it sparked a rivalry between Canibus and LL but is otherwise unnotable. LeShaun returns for another smutty duet ("Hot Hot Hot") that's far duller than "Doin' It"; various other guests - Busta Rhymes; Keith Sweat; Lost Boyz - don't make much noise. (DBW)

G.O.A.T.: Greatest Of All Time (2000)
Not a greatest hits; the title is just more braggadocio. There's no particular coherence or theme to the collection, but the variety and occasional grit (the unwelcome-comparison-drawing "Homicide"; Ty Fyffe's piano-based "Can't Think") lifts it comfortably above Phenomenon. DJ Scratch produced six tracks, and while he uses Poke & Tone's "one old sample per song" approach, at least he avoids overfamiliar tunes: the sly funk "Hello" - vocals by Amil - samples Bernard Edwards's "Telephone"; "You And Me" - vocals by Kelly Price - is based on Giuliano Salerni's "You'll Never Know." The rest are from sources familiar (Rockwilder contributed yet another pornographic seduction, "Imagine That") and obscure (Self's "Farmers," which cleverly samples the Temptations' "Ungena Za Ulimwengu"; "LL Cool J" makes odd use of Screamin' Jay Hawkins' "I Put A Spell On You."). Loads of guests including Snoop Dogg, Xzibit, and Carl Thomas (the self-righteous kissoff "This Is Us"). Meth, Redman and DMX are back for an encore, "Fuhgidabowdit," while Canibus is not only absent, he's the target of the scorching character assassination "Back Where I Belong" featuring Jah Rule. (DBW)

10 (2002)
I only count nine; he must be including the 1996 hits collection All World. The most prominent producers are the Neptunes - five tracks, mostly in their laid-back extended-chord mode ("U Should") - and Poke & Tone, who produce three tunes which don't rely on obvious samples but still aren't very interesting ("Paradise" featuring Amerie). But a number of lesser lights get their shots in: Zukhan Bey and Eric Nicks whipped up the raunchy, bouncy "Lollipop"; DJ S&S produced "Fa Ha," with a banal lyric but a curious, needling bass line. And the most rousing track on the disc is "Throw Ya L's Up," produced by Ron "Amen-Ra" Lawrence. Dru Hill add vocals to the touching "Big Mama" (which samples the Spinners' "Sadie). Also on the guest list: K-Ci and Jo-Jo and Kandice Love ("Amazin'"); apparently some versions of the CD have a bonus track, "All I Have," featuring Jennifer Lopez, but I lucked out and didn't get it. (DBW)

The DEFinition (2004)
His most entertaining effort in ages is also his least expansive: a minimum of guest stars and familiar sing-along choruses, no big concept, no hidden track. Timbaland produced six of the eleven tracks (the "Move Somethin'"; the gentle love song "Can't Explain It") and he manages to avoid his usual clichés, except for the Indian strings on "Apple Cobbler." The uncluttered backdrops - mostly built on uncomplicated keyboard hooks - set the stage for some focused rhyming from LL ("Shake It Baby"). The other producers stick to the same format (the hip hop soul single "Hush," produced by 7) and the unpretentious "let me entertain you" atmosphere even makes the duller tunes easy to overlook (the repetitious "1 In The Morning"; "Every Sip" with vocals by Candice Nelson). Pleasant as it is, though, LL often has nothing much to say ("Feel The Beat") and the record's only brush with greatness is the brash, kinetic chant "Headsprung." (DBW)

Todd Smith (2006)
Guests include Mary J. Blige, Jamie Foxx and Jenifer Lopez. (DBW)


I need a beat.

 Main page 

 New additions 

 Pop: 00s  90s 80s 70s 60s 50s

 Latin/Jazz 

 Top 20: DBW JA 

 E-mail